Contract judgment enforcement: Firm lists 33 Nigeria’s UK properties, begins sales soon
At least 33 properties owned by the Federal Government in the United Kingdom have been identified and some are at risk of being forfeited due to a damage cost awarded to an energy firm, Eurafic Power Limited, by a London Court of International Arbitration which was endorsed by a UK High Court.
The development comes as Nigeria continues to battle another firm, P&ID, which is attempting to seize $9bn Nigerian assets.
In the fresh case with number CL-2017-000781 a UK High Court ordered the payment of $2.51m, £225, 949.19 and N57.9m (a combined N1.12bn based on the current Central Bank of Nigeria’s exchange rate).
According to documents made available to The PUNCH, the legal tussle emanated from a contract entered into by the Federal Government and Eurafric Power Limited in February 2013.
The firm entered into a share sale agreement with the Bureau of Public Enterprise and the Federal Ministry of Finance both acting on behalf of the Federal Government.
The deal involved the purchase of Sapele Power Plc, owners of Sapele Power Station at the cost of $201m. The purchase included material properties and core assets of the company which listed ‘site land’ as one of its properties.
Pursuant to the share sale agreement, the National Council on Privatisation issued Share Certificate 0001 to Eurafric Power Limited on February 10, 2014, approving the sale of the Federal Government’s equity in Sapele Power Plc.
A Certificate of Handover with No 0002 also showed the handover of Sapele Power Plc to Eurafric Power Limited. All assets, liabilities, employees, rights and obligations of the Power Holding Company of Nigeria were also handed to Sapele Power Plc, now owned by Eurafric Power Limited.
However, trouble started when after the handover had been completed, the Federal Government and the Niger Delta Power Holding Company began arrangements to transfer a substantial portion of the premises already sold to Eurafric Power Limited to one Ogorode Power Generation Company. The Federal Government insisted that the portion it transferred did not form part of the sold assets.
The firm subsequently commenced arbitration against the Federal Government in the UK in line with the agreement signed by the parties.
A tribunal was set up comprising a former Attorney General of Pakistan, Makhdoom Ali Khan as Chairman with a retired Nigerian Supreme Court Judge, Justice Samson Uwaifo and a former Attorney-General of the Federation, Chief Bayo Ojo (SAN) both named as co-arbitrators.
On September 28, 2017, the arbitral tribunal ruled in favour of Eurafric Power Limited.
A UK High Court presided over by Justice Popple Well subsequently recognised the award as a court judgment.
A copy of the judgement dated January 15, 2018, read in part, “The defendants are jointly and severally ordered and directed to pay to the claimant the following amounts: $2, 500, 000 as legal costs; £215, 930.60, as an advance paid on costs and N57.9m, £10, 018.50 and $11, 158.33 as disbursements. All other claims and counter claims are dismissed.”
The court further stated that the defendants had 30 days to appeal after which the claimants would be free to enforce the judgment.
In a letter addressed to Attorney-General of the Federation, Abubakar Malami (SAN), titled, ‘Enforcement of the Arbitral Award Against the Federal Government of Nigeria- Matters Arising’ the firm Eurafric Power Limited called on the Federal Government to honour the court judgment and pay immediately.
In the letter dated October 23, 2019 which was signed by its lawyer Godwin Obla (SAN), the firm stated that it had identified 33 of Nigeria’s properties in the UK which were not being used for diplomatic purposes, adding that it would liquidate some of the assets soon.
The letter read in part, “In our view, the identification of the 33 properties by the foreign counsel may pose a significant risk to the interest of the Federal Government of Nigeria if or when the report is tendered before the UK court at which stage it becomes a public document and accessible to any member of the public.
“As it is now common knowledge, in the wake of the global publicity attracted by the P&ID case, Nigerian assets abroad now stand the increased risk of seizure/forfeiture for the liquidation of judgment debts. In our opinion therefore, it will not augur well for potentially hostile interests to gain access to actionable information of the Federal Government of Nigeria’s assets in the UK such as are contained in the report of the foreign counsel.”
We will pursue all remedies available – Office of Attorney General
The spokesman for the AGF, Umar Gwandu, said the Office of the AGF would exploit remedies available at its disposal in addressing the case.
“The Office of the Attorney-General of the Federation will work within the context of the law in exploiting remedies available at our disposal,” Gwandu said.